
A Local's Guide to the Perfect Cotswolds Cream Tea
Scones, clotted cream, strawberry jam and the eternal debate over which goes on first. Here is where to find the best cream tea in and around Bourton on the Water.
There is a question that divides the nation more reliably than politics, and it is this: does the cream go on first, or the jam? In Devon they do the jam first. In Cornwall they do the cream first. In the Cotswolds we do the cream first, and I will not be taking questions on the matter.
Now that we have established the correct order of operations, here is where to find a cream tea worth having in and around Bourton.
The Cotswold Perfumery Tea Room
Just off the High Street, and easy to walk past if you are not paying attention. The scones are made fresh each morning, which you can tell immediately. The clotted cream is the proper sort, thick and slightly yellow, the kind that holds its shape when you put a spoon in it. The garden is a good place to be on a warm afternoon.
The Old Manse Hotel
A slightly more formal setting, which suits some people and not others. The scones arrive warm, the jam is made in-house, and the whole thing is done with a care that you notice. Worth booking at weekends.
Harvesters Restaurant
Harvesters has been feeding people in Bourton for a long time and it shows, in the best possible way. The portions are generous, the staff are the kind of friendly that does not feel performed, and this is where I bring visitors who want the full experience without any ceremony.
A few things worth knowing: always ask whether the scones are fresh that day. A good scone should be slightly warm, with a thin golden crust and a soft interior that crumbles rather than compresses. If it is cold and dense, it has been sitting around. Also, if the clotted cream looks like whipped cream, it is not clotted cream. Real clotted cream is thick, pale yellow, and does not move quickly.
The cream tea is one of the things England does genuinely well. The Cotswolds, with its unhurried pace and its good dairy, does it particularly well. Sit somewhere comfortable, take your time, and do not let anyone rush you.
